Deloitte-CII survey on manufacturing firms

by Mentors4ias · December 3, 2015

India’s increasingly young workforce appears to have signalled the beginning of the end for the trade union movement in the country

The survey of over 8,000 employees in a dozen large manufacturing firms including Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Steel and Hindustan Unilever, was carried out by Deloitte and the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII)
The survey covered contract workers as well as permanent employees from sectors like automobiles, steel and fast moving consumer goods across the country.
The goal of the survey was to understand the implications of the demographic shift on factory shop-floors due to the induction of Gen Y or the millennials.

Its findings reveal that over 95 per cent of baby boomers or those nearing retirement and 75 per cent of Gen X employees are members of a trade union.
Most unionised employees neither preferred to change jobs for better opportunities, nor did they want to move to new geographies
The baby boomer generation scores higher in most aspects related to the preference of unions. As a legacy, this generation had higher affiliations for the unions than the newer ones, in line with their priorities of job security and work life balance
But over 60 per cent of young workers (in the age groups of 20 to 35 years) choose to stay away from the collective bargaining mechanisms that unions offer.
Unlike their older colleagues, GEN Y employees rated career growth as their most critical parameter at the workplace, rather than the employer’s brand or a culture that promotes work-life balance..
It also found that the younger workers who did feel the need for union membership tend to prefer internal unions rather than taking the support of the larger central trade unions.
One out of every three GenY respondents preferred an internal union compare to an external one

Incidentally, the labour ministry is in the process of a periodic verification of formal membership claims made by central trade unions like INTUC, CITU and AITUC in order to gain proportionate representation in tripartite fora where labour issues are discussed.
Together, the top ten central trade unions (TUs) have claimed that they represent around 100 million workers in 2013, up sharply from just 24 million in 2002, data for which was verified by the government only in 2008.
This has implications on the industrial relations landscape